CLSG

Conceptual Learning in Science Group
Contact(s): 
Clement, John

The Conceptual Learning in Science Group has been engaged in science education research activities since the late 70's, with the help of Professors Randall Phillis, Biology, UMass Amherst, Melvin Steinberg, Physics, Smith C., and Neil Stillings, Cognitive Science, Hampshire C., and many doctoral students, postdocs, and local school teachers. Our work has focused on analogies, misconceptions, useful intuitions, creativity and imagery use in experts, model based learning, discussion leading strategies, computer simulations, and other topics. The group has been funded virtually continuously during this period by the US National Science Foundation.

Latest CLSG News

02/15/2016 - 2:08pm

Energy in the Human Body, A Middle School Life Science Curriculum
Access the Energy in the Human Body curriculum here: http://www.cesd.umass.edu/energyinthehumanbody/

01/29/2016 - 9:04pm

In 2015, CLSG authors published in the International Journal of Science Education and Computers & Education.

03/20/2012 - 1:29pm

Four members of CLSG presented a related paper set at the Annual International Meeting of NARST in Orlando Florida. The title of the set was Discussion-Based Teaching Strategies to Support Mental Modeling: Animated Images, Static Images, and Mental Imaging. Presenters were Grant Williams, Norm Price, Abi Leibovich, and Lynn Stephens and Phil Scott was discussant.

Current CLSG members

Price, Norman Post doctoral researcher
Stephens, A. Lynn Post doctoral researcher
Clement, John Professor of Education, Emeritus

CLSG publicatons (reprints, preprints, technical reports, etc.)

See the SRRI publications list.

Current CLSG projects

Model Construction Processes in Experts

This project complements and provides input to our science education projects by attempting to understand model construction and learning processes in expert scientists, with an emphasis on the roles of analogy, imagery, and thought experiments.

Published CLSG "products"

Creative Model Construction in Scientists and Students: The Role of Imagery, Analogy, and Mental Simulation

This monograph presents a theory of creativity and imagery-based conceptual learning in science that was developed on the basis of think-aloud protocols from experts and students.

Energy in the Human Body

A Middle School Life Science Curriculum

Energy in the Human Body is an exciting curriculum for grades 6-8 based on learning theory.

Model Based Learning and Instruction in Science

This book is a collection of chapters by our research team describing new, model-based teaching methods for science instruction. It presents research on their characteristics and effectiveness, exploring them in a very diverse group of settings: middle school biology, high school physics, and college chemistry classrooms.

Preconceptions in Mechanics

Lessons dealing with conceptual difficulties

by Charles Camp and John Clement. Contributing authors: David Brown, Kimberly Gonzalez, John Kudukey, James Minstrell, Klaus Schultz, Melvin Steinberg, Valerie Veneman, and Aletta Zietsman. College Park, MD: American Association of Physics Teachers. Second Edition 2010.

The nine units in this high school physics curriculum focus on areas where students have exhibited qualitative preconceptions --- ideas that they bring to class with them prior to instruction in physics. Research has shown that certain preconceptions conflict with the physicist's point of view. It has also shown that some of these conflicting preconceptions are quite persistent and seem to resist change in the face of normal instructional techniques. The motivating idea for this book is to provide a set of lessons that are aimed specifically at these particularly troublesome areas and that use special techniques for dealing with them. Ideas in the lessons can be used to supplement any course that includes mechanics.

CLSG Debuts a Website for Educators!

Website: Strategies for using interactive simulations in science class

http://www.umass.edu/teachingstrategies/.

In the fall of 2015, CLSG took "Strategies For Using Interactive Simulations In Science Class" live. This website contains a collection of approximately 40 strategies for using simulations in science classes, with examples of the strategies in use during real science class discussions.

Energy in the Human Body is freely available

[EHB logo]

Energy in the Human Body, A Middle School Life Science Curriculum
Access the Energy in the Human Body curriculum here: http://www.cesd.umass.edu/energyinthehumanbody/

Or learn more about this curriculum under Products, above.

New Journal Articles

In 2015, CLSG authors published in the International Journal of Science Education and Computers & Education.

In 2015, Grant Williams and John Clement had an article in the International Journal of Science Education, Identifying multiple levels of discussion-based teaching strategies for constructing scientific models.
https://www.srri.umass.edu/node/664

Also in 2015, Lynn Stephens and John Clement had an article in Computers & Education, Identifying multiple levels of discussion-based teaching strategies for constructing scientific models.
https://www.srri.umass.edu/node/662

Norman Price and John Clement published an article in Science Scope in 2014, Generating, evaluating, and modifying scientific models using projected computer simulations.
https://www.srri.umass.edu/node/667

CLSG Group had Visiting Professor from Chile through March 2015

The CLSG group under Prof. Clement had a visitor through March 2015. Prof. Maris Nunez-Oviedo was here on a prestigious Fellowship from the Chilean government. She was doing joint research with the group on analysis of teaching strategies for model base learning. Maria is an alum of the College of Education and is now back at the University of Concepcion in Chile. She continues to communicate with CLSG and brings an important perspective on teacher education for model based learning.

Related Paper Set at NARST

Four members of CLSG presented a related paper set at the Annual International Meeting of NARST in Orlando Florida. The title of the set was Discussion-Based Teaching Strategies to Support Mental Modeling: Animated Images, Static Images, and Mental Imaging. Presenters were Grant Williams, Norm Price, Abi Leibovich, and Lynn Stephens and Phil Scott was discussant.

A large set of model-based teaching strategies gathered over a period of several years from classroom observations, transcript analyses, and teacher interviews are examined through multiple lenses.

Multiple Levels of Discussion-Based Teaching Strategies for Supporting Students’ Construction of Mental Models, by E. Grant Williams and John J. Clement, describes teaching strategies that experienced high school physics educators utilized during whole-class discussions to engage their students in the construction of explanatory mental models. These fell at distinct levels including dialogic and model construction levels.

Comparative Case Studies of Discussion Strategies Used in Dynamic Computer Simulation and Static Image-Based Lessons, by Norman Price and John J. Clement, uses comparative case studies to describe and compare large group discussion strategies used in computer simulation and static overhead based lessons. It suggests that a simulation can be useful not only because it has a dynamic mode but also because it has a static mode.

Hands On Small-Group vs. Whole Class Use of Animations and Simulations: Comparative Case Studies in Projectile Motion, by A. Lynn Stephens, uses comparative case study analyses to compare teacher and student strategies for using interactive simulations in either small group or whole class settings in high school physics. It considers possible explanations for why the hands-on small group work did not produce better results than the whole class work.

Discussion-Based Strategies for Use of Simulations and Animations in Middle and High School Science Classrooms, by Abi Leibovitch, A. Lynn Stephens, Norman Price, and John J. Clement, describes the process by which many of the strategies for using simulations were gathered and how they were organized using teacher feedback. It also highlights some trends that were observed in the strategies themselves.

New Book Chapter in International Handbook, March 2012

A. Lynn Stephens and John J. Clement are proud to announce the publication of a chapter in the Second International Handbook of Science Education (Springer), Chapter 13: The role of thought experiments in science and science learning.

In this chapter, we review selected studies of thought experiments used by both experts and students and attempt to develop some useful definitions and conceptual distinctions. We then apply these in an analysis of a classroom episode as an example of the roles thought experiments can play in productive whole class discussions. We are interested in this area because thought experiments are one example of the kinds of creative reasoning of which experts and students appear to be capable of under the right conditions.